C O G -- Citizens for an Open Greenbelt

COG Home History Myths/Truths Documents Full Disclosure Solutions YOU can help! Opinion/Editorial GuestBook COG Blog !!! COG Links DONATIONS Contact

C O G

cog // Pronunciation: \ˈkäg\ // Function: noun

  1. a tooth on the rim of a wheel or gear
  2. a subordinate but integral person or part
  3. a group of people that believes the Greenbelt is for the open use of ALL citizens and can not be seized for exclusive use by a select few simply because it is their will.

Citizens for an Open Greenbelt is a 501(c)(3) unincorporated non-profit association devoted to protect, preserve and advance rights to public lands and pathways in Idaho for future generations. 

We are funded entirely by donations from the public.

OUR MISSION

COG is a grassroots advocacy group dedicated to supporting the stated goal of the Treasure Valley Greenbelts... to provide continuous open space along the river for non-motorized, mixed use for the citizens of Idaho.  COG's current initiative is to open the Boise River Greenbelt in Riverside Village, Garden City to bicycles, as well as pedestrians, as these public trust lands were mandated to be by the State of Idaho over 30 years ago.”

The solution!

We need your help for our legal fund.  We have three attorneys who  will represent us pro bono -- but there are hard costs coming up we must cover!

Is it feasible to return this path to the condition required for mixed, non-motorized use? 

 You bet it is!  In fact, we have been told that the Garden City Police are patrolling this path...  ON A BICYCLE!!!  Obviously, it is not in such bad condition as Garden City claims. 

U R Visitor # 11560

See for yourself!

For the past 20 years bicycle riders travelling west from Glenwood on the north side of the river had to detour from the River to Riverside Drive, to Arney, out to 55mph State Street, back towards the River on Ulmer, through Lakeland Village to eventually, HOPEFULLY hook up to Eagle's Greenbelt sometime in 2008.  Due to pressure from COG, Mayor Evans finally concocted the infamous "Wakefield Detour" which does prevent the State Street portion of the route. 

Short-term Solution...  If you consider the relatively good condition of the path and the  contributions of time and money already on the table, it would have cost the city far less to return the original path along the river to bicycle-ready condition than to pave a $23,000 detour along an irrigation ditch in the middle of a subdivision and city streets.  At the same time, a path around the back side of the lake in Lakeland Village to the western city limit (which had been promised for many years, but never delivered) was also paved.  We were told that was a $100,000 project. 

So now we have a "greenbelt" path that surreptitiously snakes through two subdivisions on city streets and along newly paved utility easements.  There are places where these new paths are no more than six feet wide.  Finding the route is next to impossible!  All this to keep the peasants away from the lovely river area!  We doubt seriously that this paving would have happened this spring if there had not been pressure from COG to open the Riverside Village pathway.  It was done now so that the City Council could divert attention from the real issue - the RV path is supposed to be open to bicycles!!! 

Realistically, this route, if it is ever well-marked, might be the preference for the serious or commuting cyclist who prefers pavement and it will allow them higher speeds than a meandering gravel path by the river.  But, the recreational cyclist, the family with kids, or the senior who just wants a leisurely ride along the scenic river is not served by this piecemeal solution!

Long-term Solution...  Mayor Evans claims that the long term solution will be to build a pedestrian/bicycle bridge across the river so that bicycles can divert to the South side of the river to connect with the south side Garden City path (where they presumably will not disturb the good citizens of Riverside Village.)  It is still only in the planning stages - even the exact location has not yet been determined.  This will take years and many dollars that Garden City claims they do not have. 

* $23,0000 was the most recent Wakefield detour estimate given to us by Mayor Evans - it might have been significantly more!  Total pricetag for this patchwork solution was probably in the neighborhood of $150,000.

IMPORTANT NOTE:  You will find several broken "links" on these pages.  In most cases, we posted the link AND the original content that was found there as evidence of fact.  You can be sure that the content is correct, but as we post "evidence," Garden City and the Riverside Village HomeOwner's Association remove the content from their pages.  They have also pressured outside sources to change their pages.  For example, the BSU Biology Department page on the Boise River Greenbelt no longer references the blockages in Garden City at the Plantation and Riverside Village that prevent the vision of the Greenbelt extending along the river all the way from Lucky Peak to Eagle Island. 

In addition to removing content from public pages, we have been told by several supporters who posted comments or wrote to Garden City from their work e-mail addresses, that their companies were contacted by Garden City and asked if the comments were the official position of the company.  In other words, GC was bringing pressure upon the individuals via their employers. 

Can you say "damage control?"  None of this, of course, is outright illegal, but it is certainly evidence of questionable ethics and practices.  I must say, we ARE flattered that Garden City and the Riverside Village Homeowner's Association are so diligently reading our e-mails and our web pages!

THE PROBLEM

Garden City has posted signs on the Boise River Greenbelt path in Riverside Village to prohibit bicycles.  In May, 2007, Garden City passed an Ordinace making it a misdemeanor to ride a bicycle where they have posted such signs.   Recently, they have taken to calling it "the Riverside Village Nature Trail."

Their justification?  Garden City officials have told the public, residents of Riverside Village, and the media that the Riverside Village Greenbelt has historically been a "Pedestrian Only" Path. The myth is that it was privately owned and it was originally built for the exclusive use of Riverside Village residents.  Over 250 pages of public documents in our possession and interviews with many key public officials say that this is absolutely untrue!

THE TRUTH...

The Boise RiverGreenbelt in Riverside Village was mandated by the State of Idaho to be a bicycle path as a condition of approval for the Riverside Village development in1980. Most startling of all the nonsense since then regarding access to this path, is the fact that in 1994 the State of Idaho sued the developer, Idaho Forest Industries (John Evans, Manager) and Evans Brothers Construction Company for failure to abide by the provisions of the "1980 Agreement." The lawsuit reminded the developer that these are public trust lands from which the public could not be restricted and required them to permanently remove the "No Trespassing" signs.   It also required them to complete the RV pathway as a BIKE path!  When this was settled in 1996,, John Evans was the development manager and a member of the Garden City Planning and Zoning Commission.  Since that time, he has joined the Garden City Council and eventually, he became Garden City's current Mayor!

For details, plese see our HISTORY and DOCUMENTS pages so that you can judge for yourself!

WHAT NEXT? 

We will provide a recap of the many messages to and from Council Members and comments scanned from various message boards at the following Yahoo  Group.  If you have opinions, comments, or reports of message exchanges with Council Members, we would appreciate it if you would post them here.  This effort is all about bringing the myths out of the closet so that we can examine them and decide if they are valid!

COG appeared before the Land Board on Aug 19, 2008.  They declined to enforce the mandate that this be a bicycle pathway per the 1980 & 1994 Agreements.  Their ruling appears to be a procedural, rather than a legal opinion.  Please see the Documents page for the news release from Governor Otter and the letter from the Attorney General's office.  

In addition, we discovered that Garden City appears to have deliberately deeded portions of the path to the Riverside Village Homeowner's Association. This is in direct violation of the terms of the 1994 Agreement.  Per the Agreement, this would require that the entire property default to State ownership, but instead, the Land Board has simply asked Garden City to redo the deeds to correct the illegal distribution.  After many delays, they have indicated to us that this has been done. 

COG still believes that bicycles should be allowed on this pathway per the original mandate...  these are lands that belong to the people of Idaho and were only deeded to the city of Garden City with the condition that a BICYCLE path would be constructed and maintained from the western to the eastern border of the area in question.  This would be consistent with the vision of the Boise River Greenbelt that there would be a pathway for non-motorized access of the people of the State of Idaho AT LEAST all the way from Lucky Peak to Eagle Island State Park.  

The Land Board suggested that Garden City and Citizens for an Open Greenbelt enter into a mediation regarding this matter.  COG wholeheartedly supports this option and so indicated to the Land Board.  We believe that a compromise is a win/win solution. 

  • Mayor Evans continues to reiterate that he is actively working on a pedestrian/bicycle bridge across the river for cyclists to access the bicycle paths on the south side.  He claims that he has support on this from other city and county entities.  We have attempted to verify their support and have not found it...  HOWEVER...

  • COG wholeheartedly supports this solution.  We think it is fair that the Boise River Greenbelt Path through Riverside Village be open to bicycle riders until such time as the promised bridge is open, at which time, we would be happy to abandon the Riverside Village portion of the Greenbelt to the exclusive use of the elderly homeowner pedestrians there.

HOWEVER... Garden City has evidently refused the option of mediation, as we have heard nothing from them or from the Land Board regarding a mediation. 

In addition, Garden City has now posted "Closed from dusk to dawn" signs all over the Greenbelt.  It is becoming clear that Garden City has a MONSTROUS sign budget, don't you think?

We continue to pursue our objective of free access by the citizens of Idaho to this area and we would welcome your assistance, input and support.  

If you have any questions or comments, please contact us!

If you are able to make a donation to help us defray what may evolve to be significant expenses or volunteer to help us work on this problem, please see YOU Can Help! for details.

SIGN IN AT THE GuestBook
OR VISIT THE YAHOO GROUP for IDAHOCOG (link below)
TO LEAVE YOUR CONTACT E-MAIL AND COMMENTS.

SPIRIT AND INTENT OF BOISE RIVER GREENBELT VIOLATED

...as expressed very well in a reply to CouncilWoman Elfreda Higgins from a Boise cyclist.  She had just told him that "the path will remain pedestrian only as it historically has been" and as Garden City claims it legally is now. 

"On moral grounds alone, I believe you are in the wrong not to allow cyclists along this pathway as there is little to no way that the intention of the mixed use of the Greenbelt was not clear to the developers of this property. A clear pathway from Boise to Eagle for all along the Boise River has been in the mind of developers and citizens since the 1980's.

Regardless of what is morally correct, there is also a series of agreements and legal documents and even a lawsuit that spells out the intention of the mixed use for the Greenbelt along Riverside Village... (See the "Documents" Tab.)...

Clearly, clearly, this is an issue that has been dragged through the mud.  John Evans and others, now including you, have violated the intention of that pathway. Yes, you are loyal to the citizens of (Riverside Village in) Garden City, but you are not an island and never have been. You are disregarding the wishes of the larger community and the law."

Interim Compromise?  A great compromise was suggested at the Garden City Council Meeting on 2/25.  Put full effort into making that bridge a reality as soon as possible.  Frankly, I think that if the good citizens of Riverside Village want a bridge to keep bicycles out of their subdivision, they should pay for the bridge.  Why should Garden City residents in other parts of the city pay for the RV bridge?  This happened years ago in the Plantation subdivision and the bridge was funded by the homeowners there.  Bicycles and pedestrians were routed across the river from the north to the south side -- away from the Plantation subdivision at Plantation homeowner expense. 

Realistically, it will be many many years before such a bridge could be funded and built.  In the meantime, open the Riverside Village greenbelt to mixed use.  When the bridge is complete, perhaps, the RV path could be returned to "pedestrian only" status as the residents there wish it to be.